Benny's Brown Bag Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Benny's Brown Bag, a charming sandwich haven located at 1100 Elm St, Peekskill, NY. This Asian, Black, and women-owned eatery is dedicated to crafting unique sandwiches that elevate classic flavors. Their menu boasts delightful combinations, like the Chili Crisp Turkey and the Bear Mountain Hot Roast Beef, which diners rave about for their bold taste and generous portions.
The atmosphere is laid-back, and while it’s primarily a takeout venue, a nearby park offers a great picnic spot. The friendly staff enhances the experience, making every visit memorable. Not just limited to sandwiches, they offer a variety of engaging snacks and drinks that pair well with their food. Plus, with options for vegetarians and a casual vibe, Benny’s welcomes all.
Don’t miss their mouthwatering macaroni salad and refreshing beverages, making this spot a must-visit for any food lover!
Specialty Sandwiches
Chili Crisp Turkey
All Natural Oven Roasted Turkey, 6 Month Aged Manchego, Chili Crisp Mayo, Arugula, HousePickled Red Onions On A Ciabatta Long Roll
Chimi Chimi Ya Roast Beef
Roast Beef, Provolone, Chimichurri, Creamy Herb Sauce, HousePickled Red Onion, Crispy Red Onion, Arugula On A Ciabatta Long Roll
The Bear Mountain Hot Roast Beef
Roast Beef, Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Creamy Atomic Horseradish Sauce, Crispy Red Onions On A Ciabatta Long Roll
Chicken Curry Toyotathon
Jamaican Curried Chicken, Carrot Purple Cabbage Salad, Bacon, HouseMade Peach Apricot Chutney, Pickled Red Onions, Arugula On A Ciabatta Long Roll
Bettuna Sando
Herby Tuna Salad, Tomato, Arugula On Toasted Challah
Orbital Tuna Melt
Herby Tuna Salad, Provolone, Swiss, Horseradish Pickles, Salt Vinegar Chips, Tomato, Arugula On Toasted Challah
Prosciutto Paisan
Imported Prosciutto Di Parma, Spicy Soppressata, Fresh Mozzarella, Croatian Fig Jam, Arugula Tossed With Olive Oil, Balsamic Vinegar, Salt, Pepper On A Ciabatta Long Roll
The Rachel Reubens Sister
All Natural Oven Roasted Turkey, Swiss Cheese, Rush InNOut Dressing, Sauerkraut On Toasted Challah Served Hot!
Das Hans HAMMer
All Natural Black Forest Ham, Bacon, Whipped Curry Cream Cheese, Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Ruffles, Shredded Lettuce, Tomato, German Mustard On A Ciabatta Long Roll
Southern Fried Chicken Sandwich
Colonel Phils Secret Fried Chicken, Mikes Hot Honey, Horseradish Pickles, Mayo On A Large Brioche Bun
Sky High Veggie Stack
PanFried Asian Marinated Tofu, HousePickled Cabbage, Salted Cucumber, Tomato, Arugula, Vegan Mayo On A Toasted Ciabatta Long Roll
Falafeeling This
HouseMade Falafel Balls Taameya Egyptian Style, Avocado Lemon Hummus Spread, HouseMade Zaatar Ranch, Pickled Red Onion, Salted Cucumber, Lettuce, Tomato On A 8 Hero Roll
The Fried Chicken Sandwich
ThaiInspired Fried Chicken, HouseMade Slaw, Sweet Chili Sauce, Chili Crisp Mayo, Thin Sliced Green Apple On A Large Brioche Roll
Forever Young Grilled Cheese
Three Cheese Grilled Cheese Muenster, White American, Yellow American On Thick Cut White. Add Bacon Tomato 2
Specials
Sides
Hawaiian Macaroni Salad
Has Vince Ever Told You He Grew Up In LA? This Is Our Play On LL Hawaiian BBQs Famous Mac Salad